UNSILENCED.
02 / 07Chapter II

Atrocities & Erasure

A partial catalogue. The complete catalogue would be the size of a library. This is what the comfortable nations of the world prefer to file under 'complicated history.'

What follows is not exhaustive. It cannot be. We have selected episodes that are well documented, well sourced, and that together sketch the geography and the method of colonial violence. The method is consistent: dehumanize, extract, deny. Each of these cases has its own enormous scholarly literature. Each is also structurally absent or actively distorted in the school curricula of the countries responsible.

01The Congo Free State

1885 – 1908

Where

Central Africa, under King Leopold II of Belgium

Period

1885 – 1908

Estimated toll

Up to 15 million dead (≈50% population collapse)

The Congo Free State
Public flogging with the chicotte — a hippopotamus-hide whip — in Boma, Congo Free State, c.1900. Twenty-five strokes was routine. A hundred could kill.Source — Wikimedia Commons

King Leopold II ran the Congo as his personal property for twenty-three years. The territory existed to extract wild rubber. Villages were given quotas. Failure to meet the quota meant the Force Publique would burn the village and cut off the hands of survivors as proof to their officers that bullets had been used on humans, not animals.

By 1908, when international pressure finally forced Leopold to transfer the territory to the Belgian state, the population had fallen by an estimated half. The wealth Leopold extracted built the Arcades du Cinquantenaire in Brussels, the Royal Museum for Central Africa in Tervuren, and the seaside resort of Ostend.

02The Bengal Famine

1943

Where

British India

Period

1943

Estimated toll

Up to 4 million dead (direct starvation + disease)

The Bengal Famine
Calcutta street, 1943. Photograph by Sunil Janah. The Bengal famine was a policy outcome, not a natural disaster.Source — Wikimedia Commons

In the middle of the Second World War, Britain diverted food from Bengal to feed British troops and stockpile reserves in Europe. When officials in India warned Churchill that people were dying, his response, recorded by Leopold Amery, was to ask why Gandhi had not yet died.

The Bengal famine was not caused by crop failure. Rice harvests in 1943 were only slightly lower than normal. It was caused by deliberate policy: requisitioning, scorched-earth tactics against possible Japanese supply lines, and a refusal to release reserves. Two to four million people starved in a province under the direct administration of the British Crown.

03The Iranian Great Famine

1917 – 1919

Where

Persia (Iran), under joint British and Russian military occupation

Period

1917 – 1919

Estimated toll

Up to 10 million dead — possibly 40% of the population

The Iranian Great Famine
Persia, 1917–19. Joint Anglo-Russian occupation requisitioned harvests, blockaded grain, and reportedly burned food stores. The resulting famine and epidemics killed up to 10 million Iranians — almost entirely absent from Western accounts of the First World War.Source — Wikimedia Commons

While Persia was a declared neutral in the First World War, British and Russian armies occupied the country and turned it into a logistical theatre against the Ottomans. The historian Mohammad Gholi Majd, working from U.S. State Department archives, documents what followed: occupation forces requisitioned or purchased almost the entire harvest, blocked grain shipments at the southern ports, and in some districts burned food storages to deny them to rivals or to clear land for military use. Wheat that Iranian peasants had grown was loaded onto British transports for Mesopotamia and India.

The result was the largest demographic catastrophe of the First World War. Famine and the typhus and cholera epidemics that travelled with it killed, by Majd's accounting, somewhere between eight and ten million Iranians — close to forty percent of the population — in barely two years. The episode is virtually absent from British and Russian textbooks. It is absent from the standard Western chronologies of the Great War. Even in Iran, the cynical use of the famine by later regimes has not produced a public reckoning commensurate with its scale.

The Iranian case shows the colonial logic at its most undisguised: a neutral country, a foreign army, a confiscated harvest, a population left to die, and a century of silence afterwards. The phrase 'collateral damage' had not yet been invented; the practice was already mature.

04The Herero and Nama Genocide

1904 – 1908

Where

German South West Africa (Namibia)

Period

1904 – 1908

Estimated toll

≈80% of Herero, ≈50% of Nama killed

The Herero and Nama Genocide
Herero prisoners, German South West Africa, c.1904. The techniques rehearsed here — racial classification, concentration camps — returned to Europe a generation later.Source — Wikimedia Commons

When the Herero rose against German settler land seizures in 1904, General Lothar von Trotha issued an Extermination Order: 'every Herero, with or without rifles, with or without cattle, will be shot.' The Herero were driven into the waterless Omaheke desert. Wells were poisoned. Survivors were sent to concentration camps on Shark Island, where forced labor and starvation killed roughly half of them.

German anthropologists collected the skulls of victims for racial-science research. Some of those skulls were only returned to Namibia in the 2010s. Germany formally recognized this as a genocide in 2021, more than a century later.

05The Algerian War

1954 – 1962

Where

French Algeria

Period

1954 – 1962

Estimated toll

Up to 1.5 million Algerians dead (FLN figure; French state cites 400,000)

The Algerian War
FLN demonstration in Algiers, December 1960. Independence came in 1962 at a cost France has still not fully accounted for.Source — Wikimedia Commons

France did not consider Algeria a colony. It considered it part of metropolitan France. When Algerians rose for independence in 1954, the French Republic responded with the Battle of Algiers, in which paratroopers under General Massu used systematic torture — la gégène (electric shock to the genitals), waterboarding, rape — to extract information from suspected FLN members.

The war killed several hundred thousand Algerians. Entire villages were 'regrouped' — forcibly relocated to camps. In Paris in October 1961, French police under Maurice Papon murdered between 100 and 300 Algerian demonstrators and threw their bodies into the Seine. The French state acknowledged this in 2012.

06Tasmania

1803 – 1876

Where

British colony of Van Diemen's Land

Period

1803 – 1876

Estimated toll

Effective extinction of full-descent Tasmanian Aboriginal people

Tasmania
Truganini (seated, right) with other Tasmanian Aboriginal survivors, c.1860s. A people deliberately eliminated by a British colonial government.Source — Wikimedia Commons

The British colonization of Tasmania is one of the few cases in modern history that historians describe, with little controversy, as genocide. Settlers, with state backing, conducted the 'Black War' — a campaign of hunts and massacres that, combined with introduced disease and forced displacement, reduced an Aboriginal population of perhaps 5,000–10,000 to a handful within a generation.

Truganini, often (and inaccurately) called the last full-blooded Tasmanian Aboriginal woman, died in 1876. Her skeleton was put on display in a museum until 1947.

07Wounded Knee

29 December 1890

Where

Lakota Pine Ridge Reservation, United States

Period

29 December 1890

Estimated toll

≈300 Lakota men, women and children

Wounded Knee
Burial of the dead at Wounded Knee, January 1891. A mass grave for what the U.S. Army officially called a 'battle.'Source — Wikimedia Commons

The Seventh Cavalry surrounded a band of Lakota under Spotted Elk who had been ordered to disarm. When the shooting started — over a deaf elder named Black Coyote who did not understand he was being told to give up his rifle — soldiers used Hotchkiss guns to cut down men, women, children and infants. The bodies were left in the snow.

Twenty soldiers received the Medal of Honor for this. The medals have never been rescinded.

08The Destruction of Libraries and Cultures

Ongoing

Where

The Americas, Africa, Asia

Period

Ongoing

Estimated toll

Incalculable

The Destruction of Libraries and Cultures
A Benin Bronze, sixteenth century. Most of the thousands looted by British forces in 1897 remain in museums in London, Berlin, and Vienna.Source — Wikimedia Commons

The Mayan codices — folding books containing centuries of astronomy, mathematics, history and prophecy — were systematically burned by Spanish missionaries in the sixteenth century. Bishop Diego de Landa burned dozens of them at Maní in 1562. Four codices survive. Four.

The library of the University of Sankoré in Timbuktu, the libraries of the Songhai Empire, the architectural records of the Benin Bronzes (16,000 of which were looted by the British Army in 1897 and still sit, mostly, in European museums), the Buddhist sculptures of Gandhara, the ceremonial objects of the Pacific Northwest — colonialism was not only a project of killing people. It was a project of erasing the proof that they had a civilization in the first place.

A note on numbers

Every figure on this page is contested by someone who would prefer it be lower.

The figures above are the upper-bound credible estimates drawn from peer-reviewed scholarship and archival research, and they count both direct deaths (killing, massacre, execution) and indirect deaths(engineered famine, deportation, introduced disease, forced labour, the epidemics that travel with occupation). We use the upper bound on purpose. A standard tactic of colonial apologetics is to seize on the disputed margins of casualty counts — "actually it was closer to two million than ten" — as if a reduced number were a vindication. It is not. Lower figures almost always originate from the responsible power or its sympathisers; higher figures, from independent historians working in the archives of the dead. We have chosen the latter.

References

Sources & Further Reading

  1. [1]Adam Hochschild, King Leopold's Ghost (Houghton Mifflin, 1998).
  2. [2]Roger Casement, "Report on the Administration of the Independent State of the Congo" (House of Commons, 1904).
  3. [3]Mike Davis, Late Victorian Holocausts: El Niño Famines and the Making of the Third World (Verso, 2001).
  4. [4]Madhusree Mukerjee, Churchill's Secret War: The British Empire and the Ravaging of India during World War II (Basic Books, 2010).
  5. [5]Jürgen Zimmerer & Joachim Zeller (eds.), Genocide in German South-West Africa (Merlin, 2008).
  6. [6]Caroline Elkins, Imperial Reckoning (Henry Holt, 2005), on the Kenyan detention camps.
  7. [7]Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz, An Indigenous Peoples' History of the United States (Beacon, 2014).
  8. [8]Ann Curthoys, "Genocide in Tasmania: the history of an idea", in A. Dirk Moses (ed.), Empire, Colony, Genocide (Berghahn, 2008).
  9. [9]Benny Morris, The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited (Cambridge University Press, 2004); Ilan Pappé, The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine (Oneworld, 2006).
  10. [10]Geoffrey Robinson, The Killing Season: A History of the Indonesian Massacres, 1965–66 (Princeton, 2018).

All works cited in good faith for documentary, educational and critical use. Errors and omissions: contact the archive.